OEM and interchange identifier accuracy
Evidence required: manufacturer records, interchange tables, product identity, specification fields, subheadings, query logs, and support references. Pass/fail condition: Pass when every identifier belongs to the exact product and variant; fail when a number is copied from another application, hidden only for targeting, or unsupported.
Severity: Critical. Owner: Catalog data manager and product editor. Corrective action: correct identifiers, separate variants, and remove unverified cross-references. Validation step: test exact-number searches and compare the page with approved OEM databases.
Category purpose and destination quality
Evidence required: category hierarchy, product assortment, query set, filter rules, analytics, and links from the main auto parts category.
Pass/fail condition: Pass when a category such as performance exhaust systems contains the expected products, selection guidance, and logical sub-model paths; fail when it mixes incompatible intent or relies on unsupported filters.
Severity: High. Owner: Merchandising lead and SEO editor. Corrective action: redefine category scope, consolidate overlap, improve guidance, and repair destinations. Validation step: complete representative category-to-product journeys and verify that tool suggestions do not override catalog facts.
Priority product-copy differentiation
Evidence required: manufacturer copy, live descriptions, duplication reports, support questions, return reasons, and the SKU priority list. Pass/fail condition: Pass when H2 subheadings and the Top 20% of SKUs explain verified specifications, fitment, package contents, exclusions, and buyer decisions; fail when copy is duplicated, vague, or contradicted by source data.
Severity: High. Owner: Product content lead. Corrective action: rewrite priority pages from approved records and customer questions without inventing performance or compatibility claims. Validation step: compare live copy with the source, run a duplication review, and obtain merchandising approval.
Price and stock presentation
Evidence required: commerce price, inventory source, feed output, visible availability, Product structured data, pickup rules, and validation results. Pass/fail condition: Pass when page, feed, and markup report the same state; fail when price or availability conflicts.
The historical 20-40% click-through range lacks supporting proof here and is not an expected uplift. Severity: Critical. Owner: Commerce engineer and inventory operations lead. Corrective action: synchronize source systems, remove stale markup, and publish only supported states.
Validation step: test in-stock, unavailable, sale, and pickup products with the Google Rich Results Test and a live transaction check.