Start with the conditions that determine whether important outdoor product, category, service, editorial, and location pages can be crawled, rendered, indexed, and used on mobile devices. Keep a saved artifact for each decision so the next reviewer can reproduce the result.
Check mobile rendering and Core Web Vitals under constrained 3G/4G conditions. Evidence required: test results for representative category, product, editorial, service, and location templates, plus a manual mobile check of navigation, filters, forms, and primary actions.
Pass condition: the tested templates render their primary content and controls correctly, no critical interaction is blocked, and performance findings are documented by template. Fail condition: essential content or actions break, disappear, shift into unusable states, or remain materially slower than the site's accepted performance budget.
Severity: High when discovery, purchase, booking, or contact paths are impaired; otherwise Medium. Owner: engineering or web platform lead. Corrective action: remove blocking scripts, reduce avoidable transfer weight, reserve media dimensions, defer nonessential work, and fix template-specific rendering defects. Validation step: rerun the same tests on the same representative templates and save the before-and-after evidence.
Validate product structured data against visible product facts and current eligibility rules. Evidence required: rendered product details, the structured data output, and a Rich Results Test or equivalent parser result.
Pass condition: markup describes content that users can see, required properties for the chosen type are present when applicable, and there are no blocking validation errors. Fail condition: markup invents offers, availability, ratings, specifications, or other facts; uses an inapplicable type; or fails validation.
Severity: High for misleading or invalid markup on revenue-critical templates; otherwise Medium. Owner: SEO lead with engineering or merchandising support. Corrective action: align markup with visible facts, remove unsupported properties, and correct template generation.
Validation step: test the rendered page again and compare the structured data with the visible product information. Structured data can make a page eligible for supported search features, but it is not a guaranteed ranking or click-through mechanism.
Audit image delivery for product, editorial, and destination photography. Evidence required: page-level network output, rendered image dimensions, source dimensions, format, and lazy-loading behavior where appropriate.
Pass condition: images are delivered close to their rendered size, modern formats are used where compatible, important visual content remains accessible, and image loading does not block primary content unnecessarily.
Fail condition: oversized assets, hidden text inside images, missing alternative text where meaning requires it, or loading behavior that prevents users from seeing important content. Severity: Medium, raised to High when images materially block a buying, booking, or safety-related task.
Owner: engineering with content production. Corrective action: resize sources, use an efficient format, provide responsive variants, and preserve meaningful text in HTML. Validation step: retest the affected template and inspect both visual quality and transferred asset size.
Verify HTTPS, canonical behavior, redirects, and indexability on important templates. Evidence required: crawl output, response headers, canonical tags, robots directives, redirect chains, and a sample of indexed or index-eligible URLs.
Pass condition: intended public pages resolve securely, canonical signals are internally consistent, redirects point to the intended destination, and no accidental directive blocks a page that should be discoverable.
Fail condition: mixed protocol behavior, redirect loops, conflicting canonicals, accidental noindex directives, or robots rules that prevent required crawling. Severity: Critical for widespread indexability failures; High for important isolated templates.
Owner: engineering or technical SEO. Corrective action: repair protocol rules, canonical generation, redirect maps, or indexing directives at the source. Validation step: recrawl the affected scope and verify final responses and rendered directives.
Review breadcrumb navigation and category hierarchy for complex gear taxonomies. Evidence required: representative paths from broad category to subcategory to product, visible breadcrumb text, internal link targets, and the corresponding breadcrumb markup when used.
Pass condition: users can understand where they are, each breadcrumb step points to a useful parent page, and the hierarchy matches the site's actual information architecture. Fail condition: breadcrumbs create dead ends, contradict canonical category paths, or generate thin duplicate category states.
Severity: Medium, raised when the issue affects a large share of inventory. Owner: SEO lead with merchandising and engineering. Corrective action: simplify the hierarchy, consolidate duplicate paths, and align visible navigation with the canonical structure. Validation step: crawl representative paths and manually confirm the user journey from category to product and back.