The Framework Dentists Use to The Framework Dentists Use to hiring an SEO agency Hire an SEO Agency They Won't Regret They Won't Regret

This page is written for practice owners — solo dentists, group practice managers, and DSO regional directors — who are actively evaluating SEO agencies and want a structured way to make that decision.

You don't need to be an SEO expert to use this framework. You need to know what questions to ask, what answers should make you confident, and what answers should make you pause.

If you're still in the early stage of understanding what dental SEO actually involves, the foundational resources in this cluster will be more useful starting points. This guide assumes you've already decided SEO is worth investing in and are now comparing providers.

One framing note: hiring an SEO agency is a business decision, not a technical one. The right agency for your practice depends on your market, your goals, your current web presence, and your budget — not just who has the most impressive website or the most aggressive sales pitch.

Most dentists go into agency conversations without doing basic pre-call research. That puts the agency in control of the narrative from the first minute. Do this first:

• Search their agency name + reviews — Look for patterns in complaints, not one-off grievances. Recurring themes around communication, contract disputes, or results gaps matter.
• Check their own organic presence — An SEO agency that doesn't rank for its own target keywords should be asked about that directly. It's not automatically disqualifying, but it warrants a candid conversation.
• Ask for two or three dental client references before the call — If they're reluctant to provide references at the early stage, that's worth noting.
• Review their standard contract terms — Many agencies post sample agreements or will share one on request. Look for auto-renewal clauses, asset ownership language, and cancellation terms before you're emotionally invested in the relationship.
• Look at their reporting samples — Ask for a redacted sample report. This tells you what they track, how they communicate, and whether they explain results in plain language or hide behind dashboard screenshots.

This pre-work takes under an hour and shifts the dynamic of the sales conversation significantly. You'll ask better questions and evaluate answers more clearly when you've already done your homework.

There's no universal certification for dental SEO expertise, so you're evaluating evidence, not credentials. Here's what that evidence should include:

Dental-Specific Local SEO Experience

Dental SEO is local SEO. Most of your new patients come from within a defined geographic radius. An agency that primarily handles national e-commerce SEO or B2B SaaS companies has a different skill set than what you need. Ask specifically: Have they moved dental practices into the Google Maps Pack? Do they understand NAP consistency, GBP category selection for dental practices, and review acquisition strategies that comply with platform terms of service?

Clear Deliverables, Not Just 'Monthly SEO'

A vague scope of work is one of the most common sources of conflict between dental practices and agencies. Good agencies will specify: how many pages of content per month, what technical audit work is included, what link-building activities they'll execute, and what reporting cadence you'll receive. If the proposal says 'full SEO services' without itemizing those activities, push for specificity before signing.

Realistic Timeline Communication

In our experience working with healthcare practices, meaningful organic traffic growth typically begins to appear between four and six months after engagement begins — and that assumes a clean technical foundation, consistent content production, and an active link-building effort. Any agency that suggests significant results in thirty or sixty days should be asked to explain the mechanism behind that claim.

Asset Ownership Is Non-Negotiable

You should own your website, your Google Business Profile, your Google Analytics property, your Search Console account, and any content produced under the engagement. Some agencies set up accounts in their own name and use that as use to retain clients. Get explicit language in the contract confirming ownership and access transfer upon cancellation.

Not every red flag means an agency is dishonest — some reflect inexperience, some reflect misaligned expectations, and a few reflect practices you genuinely shouldn't accept. Here's how to read them:

• designed to rankings — No agency controls Google's algorithm. Guarantees of specific positions are either uninformed or a sales tactic. Either way, they're not a foundation for a credible working relationship.
• No access to your own accounts — If an agency won't give you admin access to your own Analytics, Search Console, or GBP from day one, ask why. There's no legitimate reason to withhold that access.
• Reluctance to explain their process — You don't need to understand every technical detail, but you should understand the general approach: what they're building, why, and how it connects to patients finding your practice. Vague or evasive answers to 'how does this work?' are a signal.
• Very low pricing with broad promises — Dental SEO done properly requires consistent time and expertise. In our experience, engagements priced significantly below market rates typically involve lower activity volume, outsourced content of questionable quality, or link-building methods that create risk rather than authority.
• Pressure to sign quickly — Legitimate agencies aren't running out of capacity this week. High-pressure close tactics suggest the agency relies on momentum rather than merit.
• Reporting only on vanity metrics — Rankings move. Traffic fluctuates. What matters is whether your phone is ringing and whether new patient inquiries are increasing. Agencies that only report keyword positions without connecting activity to business outcomes are either unable or unwilling to have that harder conversation.

Use these questions across every conversation. Compare answers, not just impressions.

On Experience

• 'Can you walk me through a dental practice you've worked with in a competitive market — what was the situation when you started, what did you do, and where did they end up?'
• 'What dental-specific content or local SEO challenges have you dealt with that you wouldn't encounter with a non-healthcare client?'

On Process

• 'What does the first ninety days look like — what are you doing, and what are you not doing yet?'
• 'How do you approach link-building for a dental practice, and what types of links do you pursue?'
• 'Who on your team actually works on my account — and will I have a named contact?'

On Reporting and Accountability

• 'What does your monthly report include, and how will you connect SEO activity to new patient inquiries?'
• 'If we're four months in and results aren't where we expected, what does that conversation look like?'

On Contracts and Exit

• 'What happens to my accounts and content if I cancel?'
• 'What's the minimum commitment, and what are the cancellation terms after that period?'

Pay as much attention to how they answer as what they say. Agencies that handle these questions confidently, specifically, and without defensiveness are worth continuing conversations with. Those that redirect, over-qualify, or become evasive are showing you something real.

This section is educational guidance, not legal advice. Have a qualified attorney review any contract before you sign it.

The following contract elements come up most frequently in disputes between dental practices and SEO agencies:

• Auto-renewal clauses — Many contracts renew automatically for another full term unless you cancel within a specific notice window (sometimes 30-60 days before renewal). Know when that window is.
• Ownership of deliverables — Content, website code, and account structures should explicitly transfer to you upon cancellation. Confirm this in writing, not just verbally.
• Scope definition — Vague scope language becomes a source of conflict when you expect something that the agency considers out of scope. Get deliverables itemized.
• Performance clauses — Some contracts include performance benchmarks. If yours does, make sure the benchmarks are tied to metrics within the agency's influence (traffic, rankings) rather than metrics they can't fully control (new patients booked, revenue).
• Minimum commitment period — A 3-6 month initial commitment is reasonable given that SEO has a ramp period. Longer initial commitments without strong references and clear deliverables carry more risk.
• White-label disclosure — Some agencies outsource significant portions of their work. This isn't inherently a problem, but you have a right to know who is actually doing the work and what quality controls are in place.

A contract that protects both parties should feel balanced. If the terms seem heavily weighted toward protecting the agency with few commitments to you, that's worth discussing before signing — not rationalizing away.